NHTSA Complaint #11684334 — 2024 INDIAN CHALLENGER DARK HORSE

ENGINE issue reported to NHTSA

Check any vehicle history by VIN - Free vehicle history report

Complaint Details

ODI Number 11684334
Vehicle 2024 INDIAN CHALLENGER DARK HORSE
Component ENGINE
Date of Incident
Date Filed
Mileage N/A miles
Crash No
Fire No
Injuries 0
Deaths 0
Vehicle Towed No
State VA

Consumer Description

16,328mi. Vehicle has been into two different dealerships with engine nosie concerns, 3 times total, at the top and bottom ends on right side; each said "normal." Rider opinion: when in comparison to other same model/year bikes DO NOT make the same rattling; i recently made an appointment again for september 16th to address this issue and others under warranty including a sticking throttle (second occurrence). Today, 1 September 2025, the engine hesitated twice pulling onto highway maintaining appx 75mph matched with traffic, I didnt notice any sound or signs of engine issues; continued for another 18mi. Pulled onto offramp and noticed oil all over the front crank cover area as well as a grinding noise from emanating from the cover as well as a notable vibration in the handlebars; oil was all over the exhaust and right side of the motorcycle including the tire and drive belt. Due to the location, shutting the bike down would be a hazard, continued down the road approximately a half mile, noting more hesitation, noise, and oil smoke/smell. I removed the "indian" trim piece covering the front crank bolt end area to find the crank bolt had backed out completely and was rolling around in the front cover after it broke a hole in the front cover. Oil was actively spraying out of that hole onto the exhaust and entire side and underbody of the motorcycle. Active dripping noted from entirety of exhaust on the right hand side of the motorcycle and visibly burned oil residue/carbon on exhaust pipe; unsure if there was any flame. Due to a federal holiday, insurance/roadside assistance was used to transport the vehicle back to my home address This could have caused a major acccident if engine seizure, timing component failure, fire, or major loss of traction had occurred. I did note tire slippage when pulling into the parking lot, ABS activated briefly. There ar public accounts of this in 2024 Indian Challengers, this needs addressed before it causes a serious issue.

Related Complaints for the 2024 INDIAN CHALLENGER DARK HORSE

Other ENGINE Complaints

#11640996 Despite the type, brands, or age of battery, the vehicle frequently fails to start; multiple attempts must be made to...

Recent Complaints for the 2024 INDIAN CHALLENGER DARK HORSE

#11640996 ELECTRICAL SYSTEM Despite the type, brands, or age of battery, the vehicle frequently fails to start; multiple attempts must be made to...
#11640997 ELECTRICAL SYSTEM Accessory and infotainment control wiring harness contain sub-par conductors prone to breakage and/or short circuit. ...
#11641000 TIRES:TREAD/BELT Metzler Cruisetec 130/60B19 66H; OEM fitted new. These tires are not covered by Metzler warranty due to being OEM fit...
#11638659 TIRES:TREAD/BELT Cruisetech 130/60B19 66H front. Tire irregular wear and vibration on a 2024 indian challenger motorcycle; original eq...
Check any vehicle history by VIN - Free vehicle history report