NHTSA Complaint #11694710 — 2019 KIA SOUL
ENGINE issue reported to NHTSA
Complaint Details
| ODI Number | 11694710 |
| Vehicle | 2019 KIA SOUL |
| Component | ENGINE |
| Date of Incident | |
| Date Filed | |
| Mileage | N/A miles |
| Crash | No |
| Fire | No |
| Injuries | 0 |
| Deaths | 0 |
| Vehicle Towed | No |
| State | TX |
Consumer Description
Vehicle: 2019 Kia Soul 2.0L GDI VIN: [XXX] Mileage: 92,200 The engine and connecting rod bearings failed — a known defect in Kia’s Theta II GDI engines. The vehicle began making a loud knocking noise and would stall when turning to start the engine within days of purchase. This is consistent with the same defect addressed in Kia’s KSDS / PI2107 Product Improvement Campaign and Theta II Engine class-action settlement. Component failed: Engine. The engine is available for inspection. Safety risk: The engine stalls unpredictably, creating a major risk of collision or being stranded in traffic. The stalling has occurred more than once, and the car is unsafe to drive, per Moritz Kia. Confirmed by: Moritz Kia Fort Worth, which diagnosed internal engine failure and quoted $6,230 for replacement. Kia Consumer Affairs refused to open a case or perform the recall, claiming it was “past due,” though the vehicle is within the 15-year/150,000-mile lifetime warranty coverage. Maintenance history: CARFAX confirms regular oil and filter changes, most recently on 05/30/2025, proving the vehicle was properly maintained. Inspection: Completed by Kia dealership; no outside inspection yet. Warning symptoms: Engine knocking and stalling Summary: Kia is refusing recall service and case creation despite this being a known manufacturing defect, not a maintenance issue. The KSDS system only detects failure after it occurs and does not fix the defect. This creates a continuing safety hazard for consumers. Kia consumer affairs dates of contact and reference numbers: 09/11/2025-#2563091, 10/15/2025-25603091 INFORMATION REDACTED PURSUANT TO THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT (FOIA), 5 U.S.C. 552(B)(6)
Related Complaints for the 2019 KIA SOUL
Other ENGINE Complaints
#11714971
Unknown but told by multiple mechanics that the kia soul eats oil and the engine constantly runs dry which is pricey ...
#11713366
I’ve had nothing but problems with this car since about a year after getting it in 2021. Constant noises with the eng...
#11711092
Sudden vibration on the engine while driving. No power upon acceleration. Heavily oil consumption. Had a problem on...
#11704152
I was driving approx 70mph on the highway when a piston ring popped off and blew a hole in the engine, causing the en...
#11702011
The vehicle had a catastrophic engine failure while driving in traffic. The engine would turn over making loud grindi...
Recent Complaints for the 2019 KIA SOUL
#11718103
AIR BAGS
This vehicle was seriously damaged in a crash. No airbags deployed. The vehicle was totaled. Another vehicle went thr...
#11714971
FUEL/PROPULSION SYSTEM
Unknown but told by multiple mechanics that the kia soul eats oil and the engine constantly runs dry which is pricey ...
#11713366
FUEL/PROPULSION SYSTEM
I’ve had nothing but problems with this car since about a year after getting it in 2021. Constant noises with the eng...
#11711092
POWER TRAIN
Sudden vibration on the engine while driving. No power upon acceleration. Heavily oil consumption. Had a problem on...
#11711092
SEAT BELTS
Sudden vibration on the engine while driving. No power upon acceleration. Heavily oil consumption. Had a problem on...