NHTSA Complaint #11493884 — 2017 TESLA MODEL S
FORWARD COLLISION AVOIDANCE: AUTOMATIC EMERGENCY BRAKING issue reported to NHTSA
Complaint Details
| ODI Number | 11493884 |
| Vehicle | 2017 TESLA MODEL S |
| Component | FORWARD COLLISION AVOIDANCE: AUTOMATIC EMERGENCY BRAKING |
| Date of Incident | |
| Date Filed | |
| Mileage | N/A miles |
| Crash | No |
| Fire | No |
| Injuries | 0 |
| Deaths | 0 |
| Vehicle Towed | No |
| State | OR |
Consumer Description
On 10/25/2022 at approximately 2:54pm I was traveling north on I-5 through Salem Oregon in the middle lane. Autopilot was engaged as I approached slower traffic 1 block in front of me in the middle lane. A pickup was approx 1 block behind me in the left lane. I activated the left turn signal. The vehicle initiated the transition from middle to left lane. Halfway between both lanes the vehicle applied hard braking action while continuing forward halfway between lanes. I tried to take over with application of the accelerator and force on the steering wheel to return to the middle lane. The steering wheel fought against me and the vehicle made a series of s-turns while braking. I tapped on the brake pedal and the system deactivated. The vehicle decelerated from 65-70mph to what I would guess to be 20-25mph with maximum braking (objects in the cockpit flew forward). The pickup behind me was very close when I regained control. If any vehicles had been closer or had the roadway been slick, the incident could have caused a major accident. I filed a ticked with Tesla and they advised this was known as a "phantom braking" event. There is no known fix, timeline for a fix, or mechanism to advise when there is a resolution. Tesla closed the service request. I'm a commercial pilot (former Part 135 Captain) and former flight instructor. I've been driving for 38 years with zero accidents. I have not used the Tesla autopilot since this incident. It is not safe in the current configuration. Tesla tech characterized the vehicle response as "conservative". There is no reason for maximum braking when nothing is in front of the vehicle. I would like Tesla to provide me with updates on resolving whatever is causing this. I would like Tesla to provide notification when the software patch is applied. Until such point in time when I'm notified the trouble is resolved, I will not be using the autopilot. Tesla charged several thousand dollars for this system.
Related Complaints for the 2017 TESLA MODEL S
Other FORWARD COLLISION AVOIDANCE: AUTOMATIC EMERGENCY BRAKING Complaints
#11634767
While using the summon feature from my iPhone with the Tesla application my car drove into my house causing damage. ...
#11605194
Full Self driving did not show signs of slowing down at Everett traffic slow down from about 60 miles to a standstill...
#11532562
During a road trip (May 2023) with cruise control activated, I had at least 5 phantom braking events. The most serio...
#11528508
An issue with "Pahtom Breaking." My Tesla Model S has suffered from phantom breaking since I purchased the vehicle. ...
#11524072
When using the automated cruise control or full self driving, it will unexpectedly phantom brake. Seems to happen mor...
Recent Complaints for the 2017 TESLA MODEL S
#11718165
UNKNOWN OR OTHER
I am reporting a serious safety defect regarding the front control arms on my 2017 Tesla Model S (VIN: [XXX] ). The f...
#11714816
SUSPENSION
I pulled into a parking lot, and noticed that my passenger side rear wheel was leaning into the car. Luckily I was n...
#11710572
FORWARD COLLISION AVOIDANCE: ADAPTIVE CRUISE CONTROL
CRITICAL SAFETY FAILURE: Loss of Driver Override and Extreme HMI/Signaling Latency. 1. Loss of Override & Unintended ...
#11710572
LANE DEPARTURE: WARNING
CRITICAL SAFETY FAILURE: Loss of Driver Override and Extreme HMI/Signaling Latency. 1. Loss of Override & Unintended ...
#11710572
UNKNOWN OR OTHER
CRITICAL SAFETY FAILURE: Loss of Driver Override and Extreme HMI/Signaling Latency. 1. Loss of Override & Unintended ...