NHTSA Complaint #11047501 — 2012 BMW X5

2012 BMW X5 XDRIVE50I PURCHASED 10-25-2014 AS CERTIFIED PRE-OWNED FROM BMW OF AUSTIN WITH 54,554 MILES AND EXTENDED WARRANTY TO 8-1-17 OR 100,000 MILES. ALL SERVICE WORK AND MAINTENANCE PERTAINING TO ENGINE DONE AT BMW OF AUSTIN ON TIME AS SCHEDULED. NUMEROUS RECALL WORK PERFORMED UNDER WARRANTY. NUMEROUS ISSUES WITH ENGINE HESITATION DURING ACCELERATION REPORTED TO DEALER, INVESTIGATED BY DEALER, AND SUPPOSEDLY "FIXED" BY DEALER. PROBLEMS WITH ENGINE HESITATION AT ACCELERATION PERSISTED. PROBLEM REPORTED TWICE TO DEALER THE LAST MONTH OF ELIGIBLE WARRANTY ALONE ALONG WITH STATEMENT THAT ENGINE WAS BURNING THROUGH AN EXCESSIVE ABOUT OF BMW SUPPLIED SYNTHETIC OIL (ON 7/5/17 AND AGAIN ON 7/21/17). ENGINE FINALLY SEIZED ENTIRELY ON 10/25/17 AT 89,000 MILES WHILE DRIVING AT 50 MPH AND WAS TOWED TO BMW OF AUSTIN. SERVICE REP STATED THEY COULD NOT GET THE ENGINE STARTED AND REQUESTED APPROVAL TO CRACK OPEN THE ENGINE COMPARTMENT TO INVESTIGATE. THE WORK WAS APPROVED AND HE SAID THERE WAS "UNUSUAL AND SEVERAL SCORING ON THE NUMBER 6 CYLINDER THAT WOULD REQUIRE REPLACING THE ENGINE." THIS TYPE OF CATASTROPHIC ENGINE FAILURE IS NOT USUAL FOR A WELL MAINTAINED ENGINE. THE NUMEROUS RECALLS ON THIS VEHICLE ARE SUSPECT IN THE EARLY ENGINE FAILURE. THE KNOWN DEFECTS IN MATERIAL PARTS ASSOCIATED WITH THE FRONT DRIVE SHAFT BEING THE MOST SUSPECT. TO DATE, BMW USA IS ONLY WILLING TO OFFER $5000 TOWARDS REPAIR OR TRADE IN (NOW ONLY WORTH $2500 DUE TO NON-FUNCTIONING ENGINE). I STRONGLY BELIEVE THIS ISSUE SHOULD BE HANDLED UNDER THE 10 YEAR/120000 MILE EXTENDED WARRANTY PROVIDED BY BMW FOR REPAIRS RELATED TO THE AFOREMENTIONED RECALLS. THEY DISAGREE.